Your sacred cow is in mortal danger Provoking the herd since 2002 

home

 Let's talk about ..
Be Offended - Be Very Offended Shoot the cow! Shoot the cow!  

S-e-x
Religion
Politics





 You Asked for It!
» Advance Australia Inc   2005-01-30 20:39 Strawman

>> In the dictation case, McDonald's is guilty of both price fixing
and extortion.

Ahh, 2dogs you a slithering here. The MacDonalds / Greasy Joe example was deliberately chosen as an example of force (MacDonalds dictates prices), which you imply is non-force (price fixing) in order to validate Australia's actions in violating sovereignty of other nations.

Claiming that dictating prices is one form of price fixing is like saying that murder involves the victim having the free choice to scream before hand. True but irrelevant.

Other readers are invited to reread the last few posts to untangle that little web.

>> I don't understand why you think Australia being a
>> corporation is essential to t's argument.

Probably because he started out with the sentence:

Australia is a for profit corporation owned by its shareholders (citizens).

If we want to start merely with the assertion that Australia is private property which belongs to the shareholders, then of course the argument changes.

And like I said in my original article, this is actually a sensible view, and raises two issues

  • Would Australia be a better place if more people were honest about this?
  • Would Australia be a better place if there were stronger private property rights within it - even if those private property rights were not absolute?

The problem with social democracies is that The Mob thinks they will be better voting themselves the wealth created by others.

Which is why I always say that if if there is any hope, it lies with the Proles.

  • Advance Australia Inc -- 2dogs 2005-02-01