Your sacred cow is in mortal danger Provoking the herd since 2002 

home

 Let's talk about ..
Be Offended - Be Very Offended Shoot the cow! Shoot the cow!  

S-e-x
Religion
Politics





 You Asked for It!
» Barking up the wrong tree   2003-10-01 16:29 24601

Not that I support the ALP policy, but I'm confused by your comments.

Somebody saves a dollar and the government matches it - so there is 2 dollars saved. In the altnerative scenario the individual would have saved less than a dollar (say 50 cents) and the government matching funds would have previously been in the hands of a consumer who may also have saved some of it (say 50 cents). So the alternative scenario has savings on 1 dollar - which means that the scheme would increase savings.

My primary objection to the policy is that I think it silly to pursue a specific national saving level when nobody knows (and never can know) what that target should be.