Your sacred cow is in mortal danger Provoking the herd since 2002 

home

 Let's talk about ..
Be Offended - Be Very Offended Shoot the cow! Shoot the cow!  

S-e-x
Religion
Politics





 You Asked for It!
» We are not alone   2007-04-27 15:15 Strawman

>> Well, that's one conclusion I suppose.  Here's another, from the scientist who
>> discovered the planet as quoted in the article you've linked to:

>> "Barman noted that a Jupiter-like gaseous planet such as this one, as opposed
>> to a rocky one like Earth, is highly unlikely to harbour life, and said the
>> finding about water vapour in its atmosphere does not answer one way or another
>> questions about the existence of extraterrestrial life."

As I recall, the fellow who discovered the planet was an astronomer, not a biologist. You are willing to take him at his word even if it is not his field??!!?

>> As always Strawman, your ability to draw wild conclusions completely
>> unsupported by any form of evidence is without equal.

As usual your trust in the Intellectual Elite (without even actually checking their particular qualifications) is without equal.

  • We are not alone -- Sanchez 2007-04-28