Your sacred cow is in mortal danger Provoking the herd since 2002 

home

 Let's talk about ..
Be Offended - Be Very Offended Shoot the cow! Shoot the cow!  

S-e-x
Religion
Politics





 You Asked for It!
» Carr vs Singleton   2003-09-19 17:14 Strawman
Carr loses control!

John (Rich Bastard) Singleton - fallen Libertarian, and well known advertising baron has crossed swords with New South Wales' rather taxing premier Bob Carr.

Carr, ever eager to get his snout into the tax trough to fund his pork barreling agenda, and knowing that sin taxes are generally a good target had his heart set on a new Pokies Tax, which would enable him to quietly lift over a billion dollars from New South Welshmen who like to dabble in a spot of gambling.

That is, until John (Singo) Singleton phoned him and promised to spend 5 million dollars on an advertising campaign even more vitriolic than the one which made John (remember me?) Hewson lose the unlosable election over the GST in 1993.

The normally controlled Carr, threw a tantrum and started to use words like 'blackmail' and 'intimidation' to describe Singleton's threat. Apparently citizens in the happy Carr-led gulag don't have the right to run advertising campaigns criticizing government policy.

Your ABC reports that Carr claimed:

"It was a direct threat that I would be hurt in this if I didn't accede to their demands,"

Yes Bob - it's called politics, and when you dip your hand in five million people's pockets you have to expect criticism. You can stop it whenever you like.

And he went on:

"Now a Government cannot change its taxation policy and recast a budget in the face of such self-interested threat and I won't."

Apparently citizens wishing to keep their own money is called 'self-interest', but a greedy government wanting to take it off them isn't. Scratch the surface, put him under a little stress, and Carr's socialist mindset comes bubbling to the surface almost immediately.

Clearly Carr thinks taxes are too low - if citizens were taxed highly enough, none of them would have the money to fund these kinds of anti-government campaigns. Only the government would have the funds to run campaigns, and these would be unlikely to be anti-tax.

Few Australians associate Singo' with personal freedom - he is a shark who will sell himself to the highest bidder, (like the right wing faction of the ALP) However many of his views are quite Libertarian, and his book Rip Van Australia (1977) offers a powerful and provocative insight into libertarian issues, even though it's a little dated.

After much huffing and puffing, both sides eased up on the rhetoric, and it looks like some kind of compromise was reached behind the scenes. Singleton would be a pretty tough nut to crack, and Carr would be in for a bumpy ride if he tried to roll over him. A short drive to Canberra may be Carr's best option.