Your sacred cow is in mortal danger Provoking the herd since 2002 

home

 Let's talk about ..
Be Offended - Be Very Offended Shoot the cow! Shoot the cow!  

S-e-x
Religion
Politics





 You Asked for It!
» Re: Are you mad?   2002-10-22 13:58 24601

hello :)

> > Would it not matter more to you if it were a member of your immediate family?

I would be more upset - yes I personally know and care about these people

> > What about cousins? In-laws? Friend of a friend?...

I would be more upset - yes I personally know and care about these people.

In the case of a friend of a friend - I would be more upset because of the impact on my friend.

> > ..if you follow this line for long enough you will come to fellow countrymen...

I don't know them all! Look, despite my wit, charm and amazing good looks - some Australians still haven't fallen under my spell... :)

> > then eventually onto fellow human beings.

I don't know them either... well, not all of them. yet...

> > Its only natural that most Australians are effected more by 100 of 'their own' being murdered in Bali

Indeed, because people identify with their nation, they feel these people are closer to them.

Personally (and this is just me) I try not to discriminate for or against people based based on race, religion, sex, sexual preference, or their bread of passport... etc

If I know a person - I'm sad when they're sad (because my utility function includes the utility of my friends and associates).

If I don't know the person - I'm sad, but not as sad. It's unfortunate - but if I was sad everytime a stranger died I'd be permanantly miserable!

This is the distinction I draw. I'm not more upset when a white guy is killed than a black guy. I'm not more upset when a straight guy is killed rather than a lesbian. I'm not more upset when a christian I don't know from Broome is killed rather than a hindu from suva, fiji. If I don't them - it's unfortunate, but not personal for me.

but each person is free to (I believe) discriminate for or against any group they choose, as long as they don't use govt money (ie my money) to do it.

24601