Your sacred cow is in mortal danger Provoking the herd since 2002 

home

 Let's talk about ..
Be Offended - Be Very Offended Shoot the cow! Shoot the cow!  

S-e-x
Religion
Politics





 You Asked for It!
» Policy Overboard   2010-07-07 20:23 Strawman
Reelection chances refloated

Every proponent of free markets likes to watch an auction. An auction cuts through the socialist rhetoric about needs, social justice, and humanitarianism. The rubbish about 'the rights of the stakeholders' counts for nothing. The auctioneer doesn't care how much you want something. Saying 'but I really, really want it' doesn't cut much at an auction. The auctioneer will just sell to the highest bidder. If you want it more than the other guy, you'll bid more for it.

And of course politicians big against each other for votes. Usually they get elected by promising to spend more money than their opponent, but there are bids on other things too. US politicians are well known for having execution auctions ('vote for me because I'll execute more convicts than my opponent'), but in Australia we are more civilized, and politicians normally confine their auctioneering to wasting greater and greater sums of hard-earned for taxpayers money.

Well, normally.

Astonishingly, yesterday saw a policy auction between Australian politicians which didn't simply involve spending more money. This auction was about asylum seekers. The Labour and Liberal parties were having a 'we'll deport more asylum seekers than you will' day.

Julia Australia-needs-a-woman's-compassion Gillard threw down the gauntlet by proclaiming that people should not be labelled 'rednecks' simply for expressing concern over the ever increasing number of boaties.

Then Tony he-man Abbott started the bidding by saying that he would immediately send anyone back who deliberately destroyed their documentation (asylum seekers are well known for throwing their documentation overboard just before being picked up by Australian Authorities - it makes it harder for Australian Authorities to disprove fabricated claims, and helps to protect their employees - the so called 'people smugglers', who supply transport, logistics, GPS units and the satellite phones they use to ring the Australian navy, demanding to be 'rescued').

So Julia look-at-what-I'm-wearing Gillard promised to set up an offshore processing center in East Timor. Uninvited boaties would be sent to the center to have their claims processed, and many (like nearly everyone from Sri Lanka) would never even step foot on Australian soil.

Of course Julia's solution was nothing like Johnny we-will-decide-who-comes-here-and-the-manner-in-which-they-do-so Howard's 'Pacific Solution'. No no. Little Johnny's solution was to have forlorn and destitute asylum seekers in Nauru and Papua New Guinea. Julia's solution is to have forlorn and destitute asylum seekers in East Timor. See the difference? Umm .. anyway ..

This is actually a master stroke by the fashion challenged PM. Because they couldn't possibly reuse infrastructure set by the previous government in Nauru or Papua (that would be inhumane), negotiating with the East Timorese, choosing a site, and setting up the much-more-humane infrastructure in East Timor, will all take time. That is, Dear Reader, it can't possibly happen until after the next election.

In other words, Julia can call the election, and survive the election campaign without actually doing anything - just making more promises.

Nice work if you can get it.

There will be a few awkward moments after the election of course (having to explain why the promised policy changes are now suddenly totally inappropriate), but that is what politicians do. And everything in politics is about winning the next election - focussing on later elections is pointless if the next election is lost, particularly with the half-life of the average political leader resembling a Chernobyl meltdown.

So Julia has found a solution to take her through an election win. Not a Pacific Solution, not even really a Timor Sea solution. Just a temporary solution. Until the next Labour back flip.

Julia is seeking asylum in the rhetoric of a tough border protection policy.


 Submit Your Own Comments