Your sacred cow is in mortal danger Provoking the herd since 2002 

home

 Let's talk about ..
Be Offended - Be Very Offended Shoot the cow! Shoot the cow!  

S-e-x
Religion
Politics





 You Asked for It!
» Simon Crean - Moron in waiting   2003-03-20 17:37 Strawman
Nobody's Fool

The first causality of war is normally the truth, but in Operation Iraqi Freedom, this honor might be Simon Crean's. He has said that Australia's actions are illegal, and that Australia has broken international law.

Simon's problem (like most leftists) is an inability to think ahead. Many leftist policies sound good until the longer term costs are considered, and Simon suffers the same myopia.

If Simon were to win the prime-ministership in the next election, Australia would have a prime minister who, by his own admission, agrees that Australia has illegally invaded another country. Australia would be liable for reparations and Australian soldiers, having signed up for Australia's defense and sent to gulf without given a choice, would be liable for prosecution as war criminals.

Someone clearly pointed out this error today, and he has been repeating the mantra, but with the repeated clarification "but the decision itself does not expose Australian troops to legal action as a consequence." He thinks that this will save his skin.

Of course this is nonsense. The point is that he will have admitted the actions were illegal, regardless of whether (in his opinion) action can be taken or not. If you admit to a crime, you admit to a crime. How often you insist 'but I can't be prosecuted for it', is irrelevant.

At the next election voters may be given the choice of voting for someone who insists that Australia acted correctly, or someone who admits illegality, and therefore leaves Australia (and Australians) vulnerable to international legal actions (regardless of whether he insists that action can be taken or not).

On the other hand, Australians may not be given that choice. The powerbrokers in the ALP may offer another prime-ministerial contender.

Strictly speaking, shooting yourself in the foot can count you as a war casualty, though self-inflicted injuries get you little sympathy.