Your sacred cow is in mortal danger Provoking the herd since 2002 

home

 Let's talk about ..
Be Offended - Be Very Offended Shoot the cow! Shoot the cow!  

S-e-x
Religion
Politics





 You Asked for It!
» Political Waves in Pacific Solution   2003-01-12 14:33 Strawman
Nauru - Australia's Detention Outhouse

Members of the the ALP have been desperate to link Nauru's recent political coup with Australia's 'Pacific Solution', involving over 1000 asylumseekers on the small island nation.

The usual weasel words were emanating from the ALP's Kevin (never-commit-to-anything) Rudd about the pacific solution being 'controversial', and Australia being responsible for 'contributing to instability in the Pacific', but beyond that, couldn't actually link the two. His implication is that Australia's pressuring Nauru to accept the asylum seekers has caused a leadership spill.

The truth is quite different. Nauru is much like the rest of the Pacific islands - run by a corrupt and incompetent government. The difference is that Nauru used to be rich, and none of the other islands were. Nauru had reserves of $AU2Billion dollars from its now exhausted phosphate mining operation. The money has been squandered by corruption and incompetence, and the mining operations have stripped the entire island to the point where nothing can now be grown on it.

All of this is rather sad, but not as sad as the fact that even now, the country's leaders won't tell the people the true state of their financial affairs, so they just limp from debt repayment to debt repayment. The government has changed nine times in six years, and each successive administration knows that as soon as they make the information public they will be thrown out.

So the people put up with being kept in the dark, because maybe it's better not to know.

The arrival of 1050-odd asylum seekers to the island brought a badly needed $AU30Million in aid, and allowed the government to limp along some more. It also brought in other money, as Australian government officials, detention center workers and ever the occasional journalist came to Nauru and spent money.

And apart from the occasional tantrum from former president Rene Harris who ranted about the asylum seekers being a 'Pacific Nightmare', things have run pretty well. The tantrum was basically about the arrangement being open-ended, and Rene needed to know how long his desperately needed drip-feed was going to last. So little pork - so many barrels.

But currently, public servants are 4 weeks behind on their pay, there is no cash on the islasnd, and the asylum seekers are eating better than the Naruans. Nauruans have gotten restless again, and governments have to look like they are doing something. The Nauruans thinks that if they continually change governments they will find one who will make them rich again.

So in fact Australia's pacific solution didn't cause instability at all - it allowed Rene Harris to keep power longer than he otherwise would have.

But as usual, the ALP never let the truth stand in the way of their 8 second political sound-byte. They have no alternative, just a 'non-specific solution'.