Your sacred cow is in mortal danger Provoking the herd since 2002 

home

 Let's talk about ..
Be Offended - Be Very Offended Shoot the cow! Shoot the cow!  

S-e-x
Religion
Politics





 You Asked for It!
» Working for the Dole - down on the Farm   2002-12-05 08:24 Strawman
Government Policy

ABC-2002-12-05 reveals the latest piece of interventionist idiocy 'under consideration' from the government is to assist drought-stricken farmers by throwing a current unused resource at them - people working for the dole. The plan is to move these people away from sweeping roads or whatever they currently do, into something useful - building infrastructure for the governments latest pet corporate welfare recipients - farmers.

Unfortunately for them, the Australian Workers Union AWU has kicked up, pointing out that if farmers can get the workers for nothing, then current employees will lose their jobs. A rare example of insight from a union!

The whole issue points out the idiocy of a work for the dole scheme. The 'dolees' can either

  • Do something useful; or
  • Do something useless

If they are doing something useful (ie something which would be worth paying money for), then someone is already being paid to do it, so you are just creating more unemployment (less people paying tax, and more people getting welfare).

On the other hand if they are doing something useless, then what's the point?

The logical conclusion of work-for-the-dole is to sack everyone, and put everyone onto work for the dole schemes - ie run a command economy. For a government ostensibly opposed such a system they are flirting with the prospect to a disturbing extent.

It's the old story - the government has to appear to be doing something, and doing something which makes the situation worse is better than doing nothing at all.